Who would Win: Bf1942 or BFV?

[Anonymous]

Many would think, that bBfv would wins hands down, however What about when u throw Secret weapons of ww2 into the frey?
Preanalasys: Bfv has better infantry weapons, and Has much better helicopters, however BF1942 has great AA defences and has battleships.
The best of BFV vs. The best of BF1942
Automatic/Assault Rifle: AK-47 vs. StG44
BFV: The AK-47 seems to pack more punch than the StG 44; still the StG44 can do well
Rifle: M14 vs. M-1 Garand
BFV: M14 hits harder, a little less accurate but u doesn’t have that dreaded ping, and you have a bigger clip.
SMG: MAT-49 vs. Thompson
BF1942: Thompson hits hard and fires faster.
Pistol M1911vs M1911
TIE
Machine Gun: M60 vs. Type 99
BFV: Idk, M60 fires faster, longer ranged bigger clips and hits much harder. Who do u think will win?
Anti-Tank: LAW vs Bazooka
BFV: Law is easier to use.
Sniper Rifle: SVD vs G43 Z U
Tie: Semi auto and deliver a 1 shot kill.

Interceptor: MiG 21 vs. XF-85 Goblin
BF1942: The goblin may fragile, but it sure is not easy to hit. Though the MiG 21 has radar, The goblin is much more nimble and has 4 MG compared to 1. Itts hard to judge which one is faster in game, but it might actually be the Goblin
Strategic Bomber: C-47Spooky vs. JU88A
BF1942. The Juss8 has better defensive armament, its as simple as that.
Dive Bomber: MiG17 vs. Ho229
BFV: The MiG17 has radar.
Helicopter: Cobra vs. Flettner
BFV: No contest here, the cobra has every advantage.

Heavy Tank: Patton vs. Tiger
TIE: In terms of in Game If anything the tiger is better. However, really its to close to call.
Medium Tank: PT-76 vs. Sherman T-34
BF1942. The Sherman has a rocket launcher on it. Who cares about it not being amphibious?
AA Tank: ZSU vs. Flakpanzer
BF1942: This is a real difference maker, The Flakpanzer wins hands down. It’s more durable, has more guns and protects the crew better than the ZSU.
APC: BTR-90 vs. M3A1 Special
BF1942: You could argue either way. But what it comes down to is The M3 special has a mortar and is a spawn point.
Fixed AA: Quad.50 vs. Flak38
BF1942: The Flak 38 has unlimited ammo, protects the user well, can damage EVERY single vehicle, even ships.
Jeep: 469 vs. Swimmwagen
Bf1942: The Swimmwagen has an MG-42, and is ambhipious.
Patrol Boat: PBR vs. Elect80
Bf1942: 1 reason only The Elect-80 has torpedoes and anti ship mines. Both of which are meant to take out large ships. I have no idea what would happen if a PT76 or BTR were to be hit by one, but I would imagine it would be certain death
Landing Boat: Tango vs. PrinceOW
Bf1942,: You have 10 14inch guns, two landing craft, and 6 dual AA guns.

 

[Soldier]

simple solution

Battlefield 2 would win
lol

 

[CommandoBeta]

BFV. Everything is better, the airplanes of 1942 dont stand a chance, the AA doesnt, and radar makes it so easy to destroy land targets. Guns are also better in BFV, as well as the tanks.

 

[Soldier]

there is no need to discuss, BFV is much better,
i have played BF1942, but i didnt play it more then 10-15 hours because it is boring
(i have only played the original BF1942, not the add ons, although i have them, but i was lazy to install it)

 

[Anonymous]

Byrd will disagree. BF1942 Has much better AA defences, yes BFV has the SA-7, but the Flakpanzer Fires 3-4x as fast as the ZSU has equal or better elevation and has better durability all around, the flak panzer would devastate Helicopters, Aircraft, supportvehicles, infantry and maybe even other tanks; while the AA gun hits tremandously hard, it can kill infantry, aircraft tanks, even bttleships (i have taken down battleships with an aa gun). BF1942 has the Goblin (which learned to fly in), which is defitaely faster than the Mig 21, much more manuverable, alot smaller and has 4 machine guns, is extremely responsive and therefore very erratic. bfv has radar, but radar stoops decting enemies at a certain altitude, nutrealziling tht. Tanks are right about equal in Bfv nd Bf1942. Naval Warfare goes to bf1942 hands down. BFV definately wins in most of the infantry weapons, and in helicopters. I would say the bttle would be close, and theres only one way to find out. But i doubt anyone would beable to mod bfv to accomadate the best bf1942 ehicles and weapons.

 

[BigPinkPig]

bf 1942 planes are so super good. BFV guns are good,choppers! and i like vietnam more, i thing its cool.

 

[Anonymous]

bf 1942 planes are so super good. BFV guns are good,choppers!...

i couldnt agree with that part of your statement more pink.

 

[Col. Hannibal Smith]

any pistol on BFV would beat BF42. That's because on BF42 there isn't such a thing as semi automatic. it's too damn slow! however, transportation wise, the 1942 is better because vehicles are more abundant than on BFV. PS I would rather fly a B17 than a C47 any day of the week (neither of which can really move like that in real life). I think we need to do a supermod where BFV has the WWII mod with Battleships, aircraft carriers, jets, quad 50 cals on PBRs or higgins boats, everyone gets BF2 weps and choppers, AND there's a kit where you throw rocks and your knife is a stick!!!

 

[Anonymous]

any pistol on BFV would beat BF42. That's because on BF42 there isn't such a thing as semi automatic. it's too damn slow! however, transportation wise, the 1942 is better because vehicles are more abundant than on BFV. PS I would rather fly a B17 than a C47 any day of the week (neither of which can really move like that in real life).

The first 2 sentances of your statement is completely false. The m1911 is the same in bf1942 as BFV, However in bf1942 players are much more consevative with the ammo because the sniper class and Anti tank class has no back up close range weapon (Sniperrifles in bf1942 do not have sites when zoomed out for those of you who do not know). Transportation wise its a daw, or maybe in bfvs favor, Bf1942 does have c47 and landing craft, but bfv has helis and amphibious apcs. I dont know why you include the b17 thing; because b17 is a heavy bomber and is less maneverable than the c47.

I think we need to do a supermod where BFV has the WWII mod with Battleships, aircraft carriers, jets, quad 50 cals on PBRs or higgins boats, everyone gets BF2 weps and choppers, AND there's a kit where you throw rocks and your knife is a stick!!

NO. Thats fairly errelevant to this topic anyway, this topic discusses BFV vs BF1942, not BF2. If any mod would be done realating to this topic it It would be making a mod with one team having bfv weapons the other having bf1942 weapons, also ininserted in a mod would be the best vehicles of BF1942.